Victor, Columbia and Brunswick Pressings in the '20s
by Brian Boyd
If you
are a collector
with
sharp
eyes,
you
may
have wondered why the labels on some copies of a
record
from
the
late
1920s
don't
look
quite
the
same
as
other
copies,
yet
they
have
exactly
the
same
catalog
number
and
both
were
pressed
and
issued
by
the
same
U.S.
company.
Perhaps
its
because they
come from pressing
plants on opposite
sides
of the
continent.
By
the
mid-1920s,
Victor,
Columbia,
and
Brunswick
had
all
established
pressing facilities on the West
Coast.
This allowed
them
to
manufacture
and distribute their
products
to
the
western
states
much
more
cheaply.
The
population west of the Rockies was growing rapidly,
particularly
in
California,
and
it
made
good
economic sense to save on
transcontinental
shipping
costs.
Victor's
Oakland pressing plant was opened around
1923, and facilities were further expanded in 1927.
For a
short
time,
the
Oakland
pressings
used a
different
typeface
from
their Camden
equivalents.
Some Victor executive concerned about the corporate
image
obviously
thought
better of this,
however,
and
by
1924
or
1925,
the
Oakland
labels
were
virtually
identical
to the Camden labels.
Song and
title credits
are
exactly
the same,
even
down
to
typographical
errors! Only one small, but important,
feature
allows
the observant collector
to tell
them
apart:
Oakland Victor's have a small
"O"
printed at
the
top
of
the
label,
just
above
the
Nipper
trademark.
As the label design changed, the position
of
the
"O"
moved
slightly,
but apart
from
these
minor
modifications,
Victor
continued
this
practice
into the early 1930s.
Does anyone know if there are
Oakland
Bluebirds
with the
same
identifying
mark?
Columbia's
Hollywood
facility seems to have opened
around
1926
or
1927,
and
pressed
not
only
the
Columbia
label
but
also
Okeh,
Harmony,
Velvet
Tone,
and
the rare
Odeon
ONY-
and
Parlophone
PNY-
series.
Most Columbia
West
Coast
pressings
can be
distinguished
by the typeface on the label.
While
by
1927
most
Bridgeport
pressings
used a
simple sans-serif type for the song credit, the West
Coast
pressings
continued
to use a
larger,
Roman-style type for both
song and title credits.
It appears
that not all
West
Coast
Columbias
used
locally
printed
labels,
however.
Occasionally
one
turns
up
bearing
an
identical
label
to its
East
Coast
equivalent.
Nevertheless,
these
can
still
be
identified
by
the
letter
"G"
stamped
in
the
wax
after the take number in the 12 o'clock position,
By
1928 or
1929, the
"G" was
no longer in use, and
most West
Coast Columbia
pressings
appear
instead
with a "C". Harmony, Velvet Tone and Okeh follow
the
same
pattern.
The
elusive
Odeon
ONY-
and
Parlophone
PNY-
series
appears
to
have
been
pressed
exclusively
at
the
West
Coast
plant,
however,
since
there are
no
equivalent
Bridgeport
pressings,
perhaps
contributing
to
their
scarcity
today. The
distinctive
typeface on all of these labels
continued
until
1931, when Columbia was
acquired
by
Grigsby-Grunow.
Brunswick
is
perhaps
the
most
interesting
case,
since
it
appears
they
operated
three
pressing
plants by the late '20s, two in the eastern part of
the
country
(Michigan and
New
York)
and
one on
the
West
Coast.
Brunswick's
Los
Angeles
facility
was
in
operation
by
1926
or
earlier,
since
distinctive
characteristics
start
to
appear
on
Brunswick and Vocalion
pressings
sold in that part
of the country.
There are
no special
marks on the
label or in the wax but the differences are easy to
detect.
For
example,
only
West
Coast
Brunswick
and
Vocalion
appear
to have
used
the
designation
"Light
Ray
Electrical
Recording"
on
their
label
during
1926-27
(a
characteristic
shared
with
Canadian
Brunswick).
In
addition,
the
typeface on
the
labels
is
consistently
different
— not
markedly
so
at
first,
but
enough
to
catch
the
eye
of
a
collector
used
to
seeing
East
Coast
pressings.
By
1928-29,
the differences are more noticeable.
About the
same time, two distinct varieties
of East
Coast
labels
begin
to emerge - enough
to confuse
even the most die-hard label
researcher.
There
are
other
characteristics
of
West
Coast
Brunswick
and
Vocalion
pressings,
however.
For
example, the type style of the catalog number in the
wax
is quite distinctive - a neat
"typewriter"
style
which
is raised, rather than
indented,
and appears
close
to the label.
In
addition,
the Vocalions lack
the small
triangle before the catalog number in the
wax,
which
appears
on
their
East
Coast
equivalents.
It
is
also
very
rare for
West
Coast
pressings
to
show any part of the
matrix
number
in the wax,
while East Coast
pressings often do, at least in the
1925-28
period,
when the last two or three digits
frequently
appeared.
However, West Coast
pressings
of
items
recorded
in
Brunswick's
Los
Angeles
studios
during 1929-30 sometimes show the matrix
number as well as the take, in mirror image
to the
left
of
the
label.
Whether
Brunswick
pressed
Melotone
at
its
Los
Angeles plant after
the label
was
introduced
in
1930
is
not
known,
but
the
scarcity
of the label in the
western
states suggests
that they did
not.
Very often, changes that were made in label design
or
set-up
in
the
East
Coast
plants
took
a little
longer
to be instituted
by
the West
Coast
plants,
which
usually printed their own labels.
Victor,
Columbia,
and
Brunswick
led
the
way
in
decentralizing
their
pressing
facilities
in the 1920s
to
serve
the
domestic
American
market.
By
the
early
1930s,
many
changes began
to occur
in the
recording
industry,
including
bankruptcies
and
changes
in
ownership.
The
competition
began
to
regroup.
In
1930, the American Record Corporation
(which
would
later
absorb
both
Brunswick
and
Columbia)
began West
Coast
pressings
of its Perfect
and
Romeo
labels.
As
the
decade
passed
and
the
industry
recovered
from
the
depression,
other
companies emerged and started
to establish facilities
in various regions of the country,
but that's another
story.
|