CD
|
|
|
|
Antique
Phonograph
News
Canadian Antique Phonograph Society
|
May-Jun 2008
|
|
| Jan-Feb |
Mar-Apr |
May-Jun |
Jul-Aug |
Sep-Oct |
Nov-Dec |
The Starr Company of Canada, London, Ontario:
Their Head Office and Retail Store, 265 Dundas Street
by Betty Minaker Pratt
|
The Starr Company of Canada Phonograph store, Wholesale & Retail, 265 Dundas St.,
London, "Merry Christmas / Happy New Year", late December-early January, 1919.
The location is on the south side of Dundas close to the corner of Wellington.
[courtesy of Alan Noon and Weldon Library, University of Western Ontario]
|
|
|
If we could walk into the Starr store in London between the years 1917 and 1923, we might meet a few young musicians such as the Lombardo brothers who
frequented Dundas Street at the time. We might also say hello to Melville Standfield of Toronto, who started as a travelling salesman with Starr, and
whose life story led us to London [CAPS News, July-Oct. 2006]. Mel's family was related to Thomas Standfield, the Tolpuddle Martyr who left England in
the 1840s and is commemorated today on an Ontario plaque at Fanshawe Park Road East Cemetery. The story of the Standfields in turn led us to Mel's start
in the phonograph business with John Croden and Wilfred Stevenson. By inquiring of Guy Lombardo Museum, London Central Public Library and Museum London,
we were introduced to the striking photograph of the Starr London store, carefully restored by Alan Noon at the University of Western Ontario, which gives
us the best insight into the beginning of Starr in Canada. The photo of the Starr store was taken by Henry (Harry) G. Hines, a commercial photographer whose
studio was at 666 Dundas Street during most of his career, between 1906-1933.
John Alexander Croden (Nov. 17, 1866 - Jan. 20, 1950), born in London, Ontario, and Wilfred D. Stevenson (1882 - July 9, 1960) from Ailsa Craig, north of London,
had both previously been in the piano business. Croden had managed the London branch of Heintzman Pianos for twenty years, then moved to the Toronto area in 1912.
On December 1, 1916, he left his position as vice-president and general manager of the R. S. Williams Piano Company in Oshawa to start in the phonograph business.
Stevenson started with Doherty Piano and Organ in Clinton, Ontario in 1900 and moved to London around 1902-03 to join the Sherlock-Manning Piano Company.
There he worked his way up to office manager in charge of advertising and accounting. He then joined the Mendelssohn Piano firm in 1915 as a London agent
[CMTJ, April 1917, p. 59]. Although this was a Toronto piano company, Mendelssohn had a strong connection to London. The head of the company, Henry Durke,
married Gertrude Wilson, a sister of Stevenson's wife Ethel Wilson [CMTJ, Jan. 1917, p. 65]. On April 1st 1917, Stevenson left Mendelssohn to enter business
with John Croden [CMTJ, April, 1917, p. 59].
Croden and Stevenson, both keen on opening their own business, formed a partnership as the Canadian Phonograph Supply Company in March, 1917. They toured
the extensive Starr Piano Company facilities in Richmond, Indiana, where they were impressed by the modern equipment, product quality, service and value of
that operation. They chose to deal with Starr over all offers from other phonograph factories nearby [CMTJ, April, 1917, p. 59] and arranged, at first, to
import Starr machines and records into Canada. They were also the local representatives of Gourlay Pianos and their line of player-pianos. They had a
store by May 1917 when they took over the lease of the former Gourlay piano agency in London at 261 Dundas. Here, they proudly displayed ribbons won at the
Panama Fair in San Diego by the Starr Indiana firm [CMTJ, July 1917, p. 51].
|
John Alexander Croden (1866-1950) / Wilfred D. Stevenson (1882-1960)
London Advertiser, Thurs., Dec. 13, 1917 [courtesy of Douglas Flood]
|
|
|
Gourlay, Winter & Leeming Pianos, based in Toronto, flourished between 1890 and 1923. The Gourlay Piano factory started operations in 1904 and by 1922 they
were also making phonographs. They were also dealers in cabinet organs, made by Mason & Hamlin (Boston), Karn (Woodstock), Berlin (Kitchener), Thomas (Woodstock)
and Bilhorn (Chicago). By 1922 they were carrying only Estey organs (Brattleboro, Vermont), which may be the one displayed in the London store window. In 1924
Gourlay was taken over by Sherlock-Manning Piano Company.
As new Starr Phonograph dealers, Croden and Stevenson would have received extensive help from Starr in Indiana in developing their business. Below is text from
a Starr Piano Co., Richmond, ad encouraging new dealers for Starr phonographs:
Starr Phonographs and Starr Records are the heritage of long, successful manufacturing experience - So is the selling experience which assists the Starr
dealer in developing his business. Everything possible is done to aid him. National advertising - in many of the leading publications, such as Cosmopolitan,
Literary Digest, World's Work, Scribner's, Harper's, National Geographic....Regular weekly schedule of large advertisements in over a score of the metropolitan
newspapers....The new dealer receives a series of most attractive announcement ads...folders, picture slides, window cards, etc., without cost...he is
monthly supplied with ten or a dozen illustrated timely ad-suggestions with copy, which he can easily adapt. Cuts are free. New picture slides, cards, booklets,
etc., are frequently offered....[CMTJ, Sept. 1917, p. 56].
|
Gourlay, Winter & Leeming Ltd letterhead, Toronto, Jan. 21, 1922.
This company flourished between 1890-1923. [author's collection]
|
|
|
There were several ads in the London Free Press of 1917 showing the Starr Richmond operation, including their claims of being only one of a few factories
manufacturing phonographs in their entirety on site. They also insisted that any disc records, including Starr, Victor, Columbia, Edison and Pathé, could
be played on their universal machines.
The Canadian Phonograph Supply Company was renamed The Starr Company of Canada on March 1, 1918, and by September moved their premises from 261 to 265
Dundas Street. Much of London's architecture still retains a Victorian Italianate Renaissance Revival style from the late 19th century.
In London, they are able to date many of these buildings to the 1874-1883 period when an architectural firm, Robinson and Tracy, created similar facades
along commercial streets [Michael Baker, ed., Downtown London, p. 9]. The downtown area has a charming and unifying use of "white" brick, fashionable in
the Victorian era of contrasting colours.
|
London Advertiser, Thurs. Dec. 13, 1917 [courtesy of Douglas Flood]
|
|
|
In 1918, the Starr Co. of Canada exhibited at the Western Fair, London:
Musical Instrument Display at London Exhibition, 1918
Gourlay Pianos and Starr Phonographs
The first exhibit to the left of the entrance is that of the Starr Company of
Canada, who have the local representation of Gourlay and Gourlay-Angelus
lines of pianos and players. A representative and attractive range of these
were shown. Mr. D.R. Gourlay, vice-president of Gourlay, Winter & Leeming,
Ltd., spent a couple of days assisting their London agents, who are doing an
extensive and increasing trade with Gourlay lines.
The Starr lines of phonographs, which have been so energetically exploited
in Canada since Messrs. John A. Croden and W.D. Stevenson secured the
distributing rights for Canada, a little more than a year ago, appeared in
full force at the fair, and the Starr company of Canada's success at the
Toronto Exhibition was duplicated [CMTJ, Sept. 1918, p. 74].
It was now a year and a half since they had begun setting up their new business as Starr representatives in Canada.
Croden and Stevenson were now very busy dispatching travelling salesmen such as Melville Standfield, D. S. Cluff and J. W. Caswell
(formerly of White Sewing Machine Co.) to all corners of the country. They unloaded boxcars of Starr equipment shipped from Indiana, and
developed the Starr record pressing business with Herbert Berliner in Montreal.
This company has recently moved their retail store and offices a few doors east
of their old stand, giving them a larger, brighter and more attractive store. When
a Journal representative called, Messrs. Croden and Stevenson were making
necessary alterations for the stocking of a shipment of "His Master's Voice"
records. Their record department is on the ground floor, adjoining a series of
demonstration booths, with the front or main portion of the floor set apart for
general display purposes. A specially constructed front with deep entrance gives
roomy show windows on either side of the main entrance. Their new location
brings the music houses of London still closer together, they being all within a
radius of a few minutes' walk [CMTJ, Sept. 1918, p. 74].
According to the CMTJ, the new
store had sound-proof demonstration rooms, essential to attracting more business and often shown in photographs in the CMTJ. A few companies
specialized in supplying equipment for such rooms, such as the Walker Bin and Store Fixture Company of Kitchener. Walker advertised modular
compartments with double mahogany walls and inside panels of fibre board, easily dismantled by a carpenter to transfer to any new location
[CMTJ, Nov. 1918, p. 60]. Although Stevenson may not have used Walker units, that company did understand its business, as an upright phonograph
called the "Walker Talker" was another of their exclusive inventions.
|
Starr Table Top, Style 1/2 [courtesy of Al Gentry]
|
|
|
HMV advertising dominated the store window in the photograph, as Croden and Stevenson always sold extensive product from the Berliner
factories in Montreal. They continued to promote Victor records, as they were more expensive and more prestigious than the Starr-Gennetts.
There are three of the popular Nipper dogs in the window, all about 18 inches tall. Hanging records are obscured by the Christmas decorations,
but perhaps show a glint of gold on the labels. On the floor are flat printed record display stands similar to those shown in The Collector's
Guide to HMV Nipper Souvenirs ( p. 503). The plaster bust in the right window looks like Mozart which was probably a nod to their Mozart line
of pianos [ad, City of London Directory, 1921]. It's an eclectic variety of display items provided by Victor, Starr, Gourlay, and Mozart
[fl. Toronto, ca. 1912-1920, EMC].
Two table-top machines are on the floor, but the grille of the one in the back, left window, is not clear enough to recognize the Starr Style 1/2 machine.
These phonographs have the tone arm at centre rear, and a metal knob in the centre of the grille like the Starr, but the plain flat lids with square
corners are different. Croden and Stevenson were selling many other makes of table-tops as well. In April 1917, they arranged for three other table-top
styles of phonographs to retail at $20, $32.50, and $45 in order to give their dealers a line selling from $20 to $400.
|
Theatrical window card, The Wanderer, in the store on the left at 267 Dundas, Woolnough's Corsetiers.
LFP, Dec. 28, 1918, p. 9
|
|
|
The hanging store sign in the photograph shows a Starr upright machine that may be the Style 3/4 or a Style I, with straight bars on the grille, as
shown in a rare comprehensive advertisement of all Starr phonographs available in Canada [Montreal Daily Star, June 26, 1920, p. 14]. Uprights like this
appeared in a Starr catalogue of ca.1917-1919, from the Richmond parent company. This catalogue showed about eleven styles of uprights, numbers I - IX,
and two larger models, the William & Mary and the Jacobean [Al Gentry]. In April 1917, the CMTJ described eleven styles of Starr machines from $65 to $400.
In 1920, a London Free Press ad for Starr's "Big Alteration Sale" mentions other uprights such as Columbia (Toronto), Sonora Baby Grand (Michigan/N.Y./I. Montagnes, Toronto),
Mason & Risch (Toronto), Pathé (Montreal/Toronto) and Aeolian Vocalion (Nordheimer's, Toronto / Scythes Vocalion) [LFP, Feb. 20, 1920, p. 14]. The sign also
highlights their much applauded Silver Grain Spruce Singing Throat, which was supposed to amplify and improve the tone of the wood horn to resonate like a fine violin.
For the most part, uprights were available in Canada but long console cabinets, such as the Style XVIII, were made by Starr Richmond
[Fabrizio & Paul, A World of Antique Phonographs, p. 202].
We can actually date the photograph of the Starr store from a theatrical poster in the window of Woolnough's Corsetiers, next door at 267 Dundas
Street [Vernon's City of London Directory, 1917]. The poster announces the play The Wanderer, the Biblical story of the Prodigal Son, which was
staged at the Grand Theatre between Dec. 28, 1918 and Jan. 8, 1919 [LFP, Dec. 28, 1918, p. 9; ibid. Jan. 8, 1919, p. 10]. This would be a memorable production,
as it was billed as "the biggest spectacle ever brought to London with a flock of real sheep, dogs and goats, and a large ballet of dancing girls"
[LFP, Wed. Jan. 8, 1919, p. 10]. Staged by David Belasco, Written by Maurice Samuels, Music by Anslem Goetzl, Presented by William Elliot, Ray Comstock,
and Morris Gest...the Magnificence of the Orient in the time of King Solomon.... [LFP, Fri., Jan. 3, 1919, p. 12]
David Belasco was the same impresario who gave Toronto's Gladys Smith her stage name of Mary Pickford.
The business on the right was the Dominion Café, at 263 Dundas, listed in the London City Directories between 1917 and 1923.
Starr Company of Canada Chronology
| March 1, 1917
|
The Canadian Phonograph Supply Company founded in London, Ont., by John A. Croden and Wilfred D. Stevenson,
importing goods from the Starr Piano Co., Richmond, Indiana. Stevenson mentioned their Starr warerooms at 261 Dundas, April 1917
|
| Fall 1917
|
Starr dealerships secured in western Ontario, Montreal, Quebec City, and the Maritimes; exclusive wholesale and retail rights to Starr products in Canada
|
| August 1, 1917
|
Wilder's Ltd in Montreal stocked Starr phonographs with manager George S. Pequegnant
|
| December 6, 1917
|
Purchased the Gourlay Piano Store and agency at 261 Dundas Street
|
| March 1, 1918
|
Company name changed to The Starr Company of Canada
|
| May 1918
|
Dominion government imposed tax on imports of player pianos, player organs,
records and talking machines, leading Croden and Stevenson to negotiate with Fred and Harry Gennett to plan Starr phonograph manufacturing in Canada
|
| September 1918
|
The Starr store moved from 261 to 265 Dundas Street
|
| November 1918
|
Melville Standfield developed Starr agencies in Western Canada
|
| Late 1918 to early 1919
|
Starr-Gennett records pressed by Herbert Berliner's new Compo Company in Lachine;
labels marked, "Made by Starr Co. of Canada, London, Ont." Romeo Beaudry distributed Francophone records on Starr and Compo labels
in Quebec province (from 1919-1920 until 1959)
|
| May 1919
|
Lateral Cut Gennett Records pressed in Lachine, bringing increased sales by August
|
| February 1920
|
Fred Gennett and production manager A.F. Mayer spent several days in London,
visiting three factories that were now producing Starr phonographs in Canada. Mr. Gennett was highly pleased with the organization
in Canada and with the facilities for taking care of Starr and Gennett interests [CMTJ, Feb. 1920, p. 57]
|
| March 1920
|
Stevenson arranged for a dealer in Winnipeg, a warehouse in Regina, and a distributor in Vancouver
|
| September 6, 1920
|
Charter for The Starr Company of Canada Limited, granted, Toronto
|
| March 1922
|
Advertisement showed 101 music dealers for Starr-Gennett records in Toronto alone, at the height of
the company's record distribution
|
| April 28, 1922
|
Disastrous fire at Starr warerooms, 197-199 Dundas Street, resulting in a massive
sell-off of damaged London stock at Quality Music Store in Toronto [Toronto Daily Star, May 19, 1922, p. 10], and at 195 Dundas Street London [LFP, May 13, 1922, p. 4]
|
| 1923
|
The Starr Company of Canada, Limited, changed from a private to a public company [IHS, John H.
MacKenzie Collection / Richard Green]
|
| 1923
|
Croden began a real estate company in London, J. A. Croden and Sons [LFP, Jan. 20, 1950, p. 21 / LCPL]
|
| 1924
|
The Starr Company of Canada, Limited, started liquidation of stock and assets [letter from George Welsh, Starr Richmond,
Jan. 26, 1926 / Companies Branch]
|
| February 1924
|
Stevenson briefly became Vice-President of Starr Piano Co. in Richmond [CMTJ, Feb. 1924, p. 78 / Richard Green]
|
| 1925
|
Starr in Richmond, Indiana, discontinued the Starr label.
|
| 1926-1929
|
John E. Roberts moved Starr of Canada from 265 Dundas to a smaller office at 410 Rectory
Street and was in charge while stock was sold off
|
| January 1926
|
Stevenson took over from R. H. Murray as manager of Sun Records, Toronto [CMTJ, Jan. 1926, p. 24 /
Richard Green]. Later he was founder and president of Stevenson & Hunt General Insurance Ltd, London [LFP, Sat. July 9, 1960, p. 4 / LCPL]
|
|
|
Label, Starr Table Top, Style 1/2
"From the Canadian Phonograph Supply Co. Exclusive Canadian Distributors London Canada".
This label has an early date, between March 1917 and March 1918 [CMTJ, March 1918, p. 85], before the company changed its
name to The Starr Company of Canada. [courtesy of Al Gentry]
|
|
|
|
Label, The Starr Company of Canada, dated after March, 1918. Upright, Style I,
showing Gothic Revival arches on grille. This model was advertised in Canadian newspapers.
[courtesy of Douglas Flood]
|
|
|
References
| •
|
Archives of Ontario, Index to Company Charters, Middlesex Partnership Records
|
| •
|
Baker, Michael, Editor, Downtown London, Layers of Time, London Advisory Committee on Heritage and the London Regional Art and Historical Museums, 1998
|
| •
|
Baumbach, Robert W., Look For the Dog, An Illustrated Guide to Victor Talking Machines, Mulholland Press, Inc., Los Angeles, 2005
|
| •
|
Canadian Music Trades Journal (CMTJ), Fullerton Publishing Co., 1916-1931 [Toronto Reference Library, Microfiche] [Library and Archives Canada]
|
| •
|
Companies Branch, Ministry of Government Services, Statements of Returns of Affairs, 1921-1930, 375 University Ave., Toronto
|
| •
|
Cselenyi-Granch, Ladislav, Under The Sign of The Big Fiddle, The R. S. Williams Family, Natural Heritage/Natural History Inc., 1996
|
| •
|
Edge, Ruth & Petts, Leonard, The Collectors Guide To ‘His Master's Voice' Nipper Souvenirs, The EMI Group, London, 1997
|
| •
|
The Encyclopedia of Music in Canada [EMC]. Starr / Gourlay / Mendelssohn / Sherlock-Manning / Guy Lombardo / London Ontario
http://www.thecanadianencyclopedia.com/index.cfm?PgNm=TCE&Params=A1ARTA0002603
|
| •
|
Fabrizio & Paul, A World of Antique Phonographs, Schiffer Publishing Ltd, 2007
|
| •
|
Flood, Douglas & Eleanor, Guy Lombardo Museum, London
|
| •
|
Gentry, Al, Richmond, Indiana, Past-President Starr-Gennett Foundation, CAPS Member, and Starr phonograph collection
|
| •
|
Green, Richard, Acting Manager, Music Section, Library and Archives Canada
|
| •
|
Hardy, Terri, Program Director, Starr-Gennett Foundation, Richmond, Indiana
|
| •
|
Indiana Historical Society (IHS), John K. MacKenzie Collection
|
| •
|
Kelly, Wayne, Downright Upright, A History of the Canadian Piano Industry, Natural Heritage/Natural History Inc., 1991
|
| •
|
London Advertiser [Archives of Ontario]
|
| •
|
London Free Press (LFP) [Toronto Reference Library]
|
| •
|
McClelland, Arthur, London Room, London Central Public Library (LCPL)
|
| •
|
Minaker Pratt, Betty, "The Starr Company of Canada", APN, Canadian Antique Phonograph Society, July-Aug., 2007
http://www.capsnews.org/apn2007-4.htm
|
| •
|
Noon, Alan, East of Adelaide, Photographs of commercial, industrial and working-class urban Ontario 1905-1930, London Regional Art and Historical Museums, 1989
|
| •
|
Noon, Alan, Media Specialist, Department of Biology, Faculty of Science, University of Western Ontario, London
|
| •
|
Moogk, Edward B., Roll Back the Years, National Library of Canada, Ottawa, 1975
|
| •
|
Surles, Elizabeth, "Why The Difference is in the Tone: The Starr-Gennett Legacy", APN, Canadian Antique Phonograph Society, July-Aug., 2007
http://www.capsnews.org/apn2007-4.htm
|
| •
|
Vernon's City of London Directory, 1917-1932 [Toronto Reference Library]
|
| •
|
The Virtual Gramophone. Compo records / Romeo Beaudry
http://www.collectionscanada.gc.ca/4/4/m2-3011-e.html
http://www.collectionscanada.gc.ca/4/4/m2-1057-e.html
|
| •
|
University of Western Ontario, D. B. Weldon Library, Hines Photographic Collection
|
| •
|
Woodland Cemetery, 493 Springbank Drive, London, Ontario
|
| •
|
Zimmerman, Arthur and Minaker Pratt, Betty, "Standfield-MacPherson Company, Phonographs What's in a Picture - Applied Forensics", APN, Canadian Antique Phonograph Society, Jul-Oct., 2006
http://www.capsnews.org/apn2006-4-5.htm
|
|
|
One Day Your Collection Will Pass On:
Don’t let it become a burden to your family
by Mike Bryan
|
Mike Bryan
CAPS President and Auctioneer
|
|
|
You’ve got to admit that our
hobby is quite specialised.
If you are not a seasoned
collector, the world of antique
phonographs, parts, records
and related items would likely
be a complete mystery to you.
Remember when you first started,
when you didn’t know what it was, what is was
worth, and couldn’t spot the repro parts or the
bodged repairs. It’s easy when you’ve developed
your knowledge and an eye for such things, but
most non-collectors would find it hard to discern
things like value, rarity and desirability, let
alone be able to correctly name each item. To
the non-cognoscenti an early 7" Berliner record
may be considered worthless because of its rough
condition, while a shiny 78rpm record from the 40s
might appear to have value and perhaps be worth
keeping. At the other extreme, a strange-looking
tinfoil machine might be considered less valuable
than a Victrola IX with its nice cabinet and ability
to play those old records so well. Such ignorance
can benefit the collector as a buyer, but can be
detrimental to the preservation of antique items left
in the wrong hands. Ignorance would certainly be
a negative in the disposal of a collection, triggered
by the death of a collector, whether it be from old
age, illness or untimely accident.
In this article we’ll look at why we need to face
up to our mortality and how we can make life a
little easier for those that we might leave behind. I
accept that there are more important things than
phonograph and record collections to worry about
when a loved one passes away. However, at the risk
of sounding over-dramatic, I am suggesting that
your collection could become a far larger burden
than you might ever imagine.
Somehow it just kept on growing
Every phonograph collector has a story about
how they acquired their first machine, never
believing they would ever find the need to own
another…and another… In antique shops and at
shows they start taking closer looks at previously
unnoticed phonographs or records, but don’t admit
to actually seeking more machines. It doesn’t
matter though; they’re hooked. Over the years they
manage to find a few real bargains, restore some
junk machine to their original glory and pay fair
market price for certain “must have” phonographs.
While collectors may regularly buy and sell
machines, most would not give serious thought
to ever selling their collection in its entirety. Why
not? Because they enjoy their collections and have
no intention of parting with what has become
part of their identity. Apart from that, they would
recognize it as a somewhat daunting task to list
and value each item. Also, some of the projects
are still not finished, some parts are missing and,
anyway, it could be difficult to find a buyer for the
whole lot at once.
You might want to just stop at this point and
consider a few things:-
| 1.
|
Do you keep an inventory list of every item in
your collection and does it show current values,
i.e. the price at what you could realistically sell
each item today?
|
| 2.
|
Are you aware of the total value of your
collection?
|
| 3.
|
Have you consulted your insurance broker for
guidance on how to make sure your items are
adequately insured?
|
| 4.
|
What does your nearest and dearest know about
your collection and its value?
|
I can hear all the excuses, e.g. the list would be
a chore to keep updated as I buy and sell all the
time… I’d have to remember to change the value
after restoration…I’m not sure what it’s worth
today, etc. OK, but if it’s hard for you to do, what
sort of challenge would it be for a non-collector
to value and dispose of your collection? I’m sure
you can see where I’m going with this; sooner or
later we are all going to pass on. At the time of
our passing our spouse or other family member
will not only have to deal with their grief, but
with financial and administrative matters, too. As
if that’s not hard enough, they will have to face
the emotional challenge of what to do with your
personal items. Anything out of the ordinary,
anything that was special to you, anything on
which friends and relations are unable to give
advice, will become a major burden. One part
of them will want to keep your phonograph
collection, because they know it meant so much to
you, while another part of them will recognize the
need to be free of this stuff that is preventing them
from moving on with their life.
A positive outcome, but it could have been
so different
All of this came home to me a couple of years
ago when the wife of a CAPS member called
me to ask for advice on how she might dispose
of her deceased husband’s collection. She had
been struggling with the decision on what to do
with the collection for several months and it had
clearly become a burden, both emotionally and
physically. As far as I could tell, her husband had
left no instructions regarding disposal, so she was
struggling with what he would have wanted as
well as trying to decide what she wanted to do
with the collection that loomed large in her living
room. I asked a few questions and ascertained that
there might be a dozen or so items for disposal.
Based on previous examples set by CAPS
colleagues, I suggested that one option would be
to redistribute the collection among fellow CAPS
members by selling them at our regular auctions.
The lady agreed to this, so I made an appointment
to see the collection, make a list of all items and
provide at least a rough valuation for her.
Although the collection was quite small, it was
deceptive. It would have been so easy to dismiss
items of little apparent value and that were
difficult to describe. On that point, it occurred
to me that for a non-collector, even the task of
properly naming all the items would be a major
challenge, e.g. "thick records, Edison phonograph
with big horn." Anyway, my list that started with
a dozen or so main items, soon grew to well over
100 items. As CAPS auctioneer, I knew very well
that a price could be had for every single one
of them, if I correctly assembled them into lots
and spread them over several CAPS auctions. In
fact, this "small" collection, initially perceived as
such because there were only four phonographs,
yielded 60 lots that were auctioned over four
meetings, achieving a value of 50% more than the
guesstimate I’d made at first sight.
There were several positive aspects to all this:-
| •
|
The widow of the deceased CAPS member was
relieved of the daunting task of disposing of her
husband’s collection.
|
| •
|
The "true" value of the collection was realized
through the transparent auction process and
delivered in full to the widow.
|
| •
|
The collection of a CAPS member was
disbursed in the fairest way among fellow CAPS
members. His widow believed that he would
have wanted it so.
|
| •
|
CAPS members benefitted from the recycling of
the deceased member’s collection.
|
| •
|
At a time of need CAPS was able to provide a
solution beneficial to all parties.
|
Although my story had these positive outcomes, it
could have been very different if the lady had not
called CAPS and made the right contact. With no
inventory list, no idea of values, but with a desire
to dispose of the collection with minimum hassle,
the lady was vulnerable to those who would take
advantage of such a situation. Sometimes we
can be aware that our own ignorance leaves us
vulnerable, but we still feel unable to do anything
about it. That leaves us with resentment and a
bitter taste. In this case, apart from the distressing
ordeal of facing unknown potential buyers, it is
doubtful that the full value of the collection would
have been achieved by trying to sell the collection
privately.
Avoid your collection becoming a burden
This story identifies one option for disposing of a
phonograph collection, or any collection for that
matter, but there are obviously more, which I’ll
come to later. The key point, though, is to make
your wishes known to someone and empower
them with the knowledge and tools to handle
the disposal of your treasures. It is important
to understand the size and nature of the burden
you may be imposing if you don’t do this. Don’t
mistake polite interest on the part of your friends
and family as knowledge. They most likely don’t
have a clue. So here are some suggestions on
what you should do to avoid your collection
becoming a burden to your family:
| 1.
|
Make a detailed inventory of every single item,
using full descriptions that will identify each
item to fellow collectors. Include layman’s
descriptions of items that do not carry
identifying words, e.g Columbia machines and
my previous example, Diamond Discs. Indicate
the approximate realistic value at which you
could sell each item today.
|
| 2.
|
Write a note with contact details of collectors,
clubs or professionals who you believe to be
trustworthy, knowledgeable and potentially
helpful in the event of your passing. You may
even choose to consult them about this.
|
| 3.
|
In the same note, and probably in your Will, too,
state exactly what you would like to happen with
your collection. Do not assume that your family
will wish to keep it and please don’t consider
that "No instructions" is a viable option.
|
The
disposal choices are endless, but some common
ones might be:-
| A)
|
Ask, and get a clear answer from family
and friends, if they would like to have any
particular item from your collection as a
bequest.
|
| B)
|
State that you would like your collection sold
through a professional auction house. Name
the auction house if you have one in mind.
|
| C)
|
Provide the names of fellow collectors who
you know would be interested in acquiring all
or part of your collection.
|
| D)
|
If you live within driving distance of Toronto,
provide the name of a contact at CAPS with
a request that they take your collection for
auction to fellow members at one or more
CAPS meetings.
|
| E)
|
State that you would like your collection to
remain untouched in memory of you.
|
| F)
|
State that you would like your collection to be
advertised for sale in this publication, Antique
Phonograph News.
|
This may seem like a bit of a chore, but it’s
nothing compared to the chore that others would
have to handle if you take no action. Once you’ve
considered your options, decided on your disposal
choice and compiled your inventory list, you’ll
only have to remember to make the occasional
addition or deletion to keep the list current…..for
as long as you live.
|
|
|
|